Thursday, July 18, 2002 |
23:33 - On the Prospects of JPEG
http://www.livejournal.com/talkread.bml?journal=makali&itemid=69926&usescheme=lynx
|
(top) |
Matt Robinson has some good thoughts on the JPEG-enforcement issue mentioned earlier, and its ramifications on audio/video codecs and the whole concept of patent law as it applies to technology.
The problems this highlights aren't going to go away either unless we (and the US especially) change the way we handle patents. More and more "open standards" rely on patents that are starting to look like time-bombs to us and hidden treasure to companies who own (or have acquired) the patents. MPEG-4 was so encumbered by licensing issues that while it's been "out" and finished for more than three years, no products used it because they couldn't figure out a cost-effective way of implementing it. Now it's 3 years behind competing products like Sorenson 3 (and DivX, now that it's getting legitimate customers and not just sweaty DVD ripping nerd-childs) and its video quality is sorely lacking. But what if MPEG-LA had just sat on the licensing fees for a few years and then started charging? What if Microsoft decides tomorrow that since it owns patents on NTFS, (V)FAT(12/16/32), it can kill off competition from Mac and Linux by charging royalties for implementations of code that reads those filesystems? What if some relic of the dark ages rears his ugly head up next week and demands royalties for internal combustion engines? Will we all be willing to pay more for cars?
To me, these kinds of stunts are what a company pulls when it's clear out of options-- when its normal business plan has failed and it has nothing to lose by cashing in its hand, a move which will make it universally despised but which might buy it some time (and some valuable allies). Unisys did this, right about the time when it became clear that they had no hope of making money any other way. And look what friends it won them.
Anyway, give it a read-- it's worth it for more than just the crack about "sweaty DVD ripping nerd-childs".
|
|