Thursday, March 7, 2002 |
11:37 - Pack of Cards vs. Game Boy
http://ptech.wsj.com/archive/ptech-20020228.html
|
(top) |
Now that it's no longer a for-pay article, Walt Mossberg's comparison of the Rio Riot (by SonicBlue, or Diamond, or whoever they are these days) and the iPod is now up for public viewing.
Sonicblue touts a number of automated playback features on the Riot. For instance, it can quickly create a list of your most-played tunes, or of songs from a certain decade. But I found these things to be gimmicky, and they don't work well unless you first run your song collection through a piece of add-on software called MoodLogic, which isn't included.
The Riot purportedly has a battery life of at least 10 hours, which might put it close to the iPod's 12-hour battery life. But I couldn't test this, because the evaluation unit Sonicblue sent me wouldn't hold a charge. In fact, my test Riot, a production-level unit, was plagued with defects.
Mossberg has a history of being an easy target for accusations of being an Apple shill; he's always on hand for a sound bite or testimonial quote whenever Apple brings out some new product. It should come as little surprise to longtime readers of Mac op-ed articles that he likes the iPod, and it's a simple matter to dismiss this article as a scared piece of FUD that attempts to defuse a threat from new portable audio players that have already advanced (through their short conception and development cycles) to be more than a match for the iPod in terms of feature set, ease-of-use, quality, and so on.
But, well... a quick read of the article should show that there's plenty of thought that goes into these things. The Rio Riot really does suck. I have a co-worker here who bought one instead of an iPod, and he's regretting it. Yeah, it's 20GB-- but it's USB, so it takes forever to fill it up. Yeah, it's got a big snazzy screen-- but the software makes such poor use of it as to neuter any benefits it might offer. And it's big and ungainly, the controls are awkward, the features are "gimmicky", and there are reliability problems. Some of these are subjective issues, yes. But it's still a valid viewpoint, made no less so by previous Mac-positive articles by Mossberg.
|
|